|
The PPA explored web-based publicity opportunities by hosting the editors/writers of some of the most influential and widely blogs on the internet today.
Panelists:
Mark Sarvas,
Editor, The Elegant Variation
Jessa Crispin,
Editor, Bookslut.com
Maud Newton
Ron Hogan
Beatrice.com
JC – Jessa Crispin
MN – Maud Newton
MS: – Mark Sarvas
RH – Ron Hogan
Can you describe your blog and the kind of book or author you would typically cover?
MN: Blog is a collection of things she likes—mostly literary tastes, and likes darker fiction.
RH: Beatrice.com is mostly fiction, runs the gamut from literary to commercial, also some interesting literary nonfiction. Galleycat is a publishing blog covering industry news.
JC: With 35 different reviewers working with the site, a very eclectic mix of books.
MS: Literary Fiction.
What are your personal interests? Favorite genres?
MN: No self-help. Likes some SF, fantasy—people like William Gibson and Jonathan Letham. Mostly just prefers literary novels.
RH: What was said above.
JC: Likes Literary Fiction, Sci-Fi, Comics (writes a comics column for the Chicago Sun-Times, as well as a weekly column for The Book Standard). No mysteries. No self-help.
MS: Literary Fiction. Loves John Banville. Likes Hungarian and French writers (because of his heritage). Particularly interested in writers under seige and in prison, persecuted writers in different countries, dissident writers. Interested in film (he’s a screenwriter as well).
Do you review for any other media outlets?
MN: Has reviewed for the New York Times, Boston Globe, Washington Post, Newsday, and a few more.
RH: Freelance writer for Publishers Weekly
JC: Columns for Chicago Sun-Times and The Book Standard.
How do you decide which articles and sites to link to?
MN: Mostly they are a reflection of her interests, takes a special interest in items about religion and politics.
RH: Mostly it's a gut check, whatever interests him. Galleycat is different, as he needs to post gossip about the publishing world that would be interesting to others.
JC: A reflection of Jessa’s interest as well as those of her other writers.
MS: Entirely a reflection of Mark’s interests.
How do you publicize your blog? Are you linked to other sites? Do other sites lead to you?
MN: Blog is a place for comments and stories interesting to her, so there’s really no publicizing—she just hopes to have people return if they are interested.
RH: Mentions website at all of his book events, also uses Technorati.com.
JC: Bookslut sells advertising. No publicizing beyond that.
MS: Links to those he likes reading, vice-versa.
How do you get your books? If a publisher won’t send a review copy, will you buy one? Do the publishers who send you review copies get more coverage than those who don’t?
MN: All of the above—buys, they are mailed to her, she requests. While occasionally she does review a book that was sent to her unrequested, she wanted everyone to know that she is never going to review chick lit.
RH: Has not bought a book in two years, prefers getting review copies from publicists.
JC: Loves review copies and also appreciates books being sent directly to the freelancers she assigns to (as her apartment is the clearing house for all of the books that end up on the site).
MS: Hasn’t paid for a book in 2 years—loves review copies of things that interest him. Any finished books he doesn’t keep are donated to the library.
Who, if anyone, do you consider your main competition? Is there a battle among the bloggers out there?
MN: Just as she doesn’t think in terms of demographic, she doesn’t really think in terms of competition—prefers getting along with fellow bloggers
RH: Agreed with Maud—just wants Beatrice.com to be the best Beatrice it can be. Doesn’t think about competition for Galleycat, since it’s people like Publishers Lunch and Ed Wyatt at the NY Times
JC: See above.
MS: See above.
Do you publicize local events? Does your coverage focus on local authors?
MN: Yes—send local events to Lauren Cerand (Lauren@maudnewton.com) for possible listing in The Smart Set, which comes out every Monday on the site. Blog probably tends to focus on authors from New York, Florida, Texas, and Mississippi because of her interests. However, on three Fridays a month Annie Reed takes over the site—Annie lives in Canada and covers their literary scene. On fourth Friday, Emma Garman takes over—she lives in England and covers that literary scene.
RH: Does not cover NY events, although he does attend NY literary events. His blog offers other opportunities to touring authors—can write a tour diary to be posted on Beatrice.
JC: Will publicize local events but also hosts a monthly reading series in Chicago. The series is held at a bar and has been attracting 50-75 people per event, with an average of 12-20 books sold. Looking to make this a twice-monthly series. She says "It's been like pulling teeth to get authors flown to Chicago" for the series, so she's open to pitches for authors on tour.
MS: Will mention events related to books he likes.
How effective do you think your site is in reaching readers and book-buying consumers?
MN: Doesn’t get any money from her blog as it is a labor of love, so she doesn’t have any hard evidence on how many people go to a bookstore from her site. However, she is often asked to review books for the mainstream media—especially Newsday--that she has mentioned on her site.
RH: Beatrice.com generated $1,800 in sales at Powell’s in the first six months of 2005. There’s a healthy audience at the site.
JC: 8,500 unique visitors per day.
MS: 3,000 – 5,000 unique visitors per day.
Is this a part-time or full-time job for you?
MN: Has a full-time day job. This is just for fun.
RH: Galleycat is a paid part-time job. Also works as a freelancer.
JC: Also writes columns for other media, but Bookslut takes much of her time.
MS: Part-time. Mark updates TEV for about 2 hours each day, usually in the evening.
One of the fears that people have about blogs is credibility. How do you respond to that? What makes you an authority?
MN: Sounds off on politics a lot on the blog, tries to cover politics as she does everything on the site: in a simple but expansive way. While she tries not to make any factual errors, there is a lot of talking from the gut. Doesn’t believe in this idea of the blogs versus print media, but if that were true, who would be more credible?
RH: Tells the story of Steve Almond attacking Mark Sarvas on Salon.com for credibility.
Questions from the audience:
Will you wait to post on a galley until the pub date?
MN: Similar to Mark Sarvas, likes to get out in front by writing about books early, but does not post unless she has something important to say.
RH: Doesn’t review before pub date—since he so often has authors on Beatrice on the site, much of this policing is left up to them.
JC: Likes galleys and will try to time coverage for the month of publication.
MS: Likes galleys and will try to time coverage for the month of publication.
Do you prefer galleys?
MN: Yes. She needs time to read the book and likes to post in the first few weeks that a book is on sale as that seems the most important time for publishing houses.
RH: Galleys help reviews happen in a timely fashion.
JC&MS: See above.
As more blogs exist, how will blogs rank themselves?
MN: Since the blog is not for profit, and never will be, this is not something she concerns herself with. She can understand how this can be frustrating and that it is hard for publicists to understand—but she’s just doing the blog for fun.
RH: Asked questioner not to describe blogs as an ‘industry.’ Blogs differentiate themselves through interest.
JC&MS: Same as above.
How many hits do you get per month?
MN: Doesn’t track number of people exactly, but gets about 3,000–4,000 hits a day.
RH: 4,000–5,000 hits a day at Beatrice.com
JC: 8,500 unique visitors per day.
MS: 3,000 – 5,000 unique visitors per day.
Do you have any favorite blogs (other than those of the people on the panel)?
MN: Check out the blogroll on the site, other than that Bookninja, Tingle Alley, Moorish Girl
RH: Members of the Lit Blog Co-Op, Gawker, Wonkette, Bookgasm
JC: Mobylives.com
MS: The Reading Experience.
Do you review young adult books?
MN: Not specifically, but she occasionally posts comments of her step-daughter who reads them.<br>
RH: Not specifically, but he would be interested to know about any that have crossed over—from YA to adult or the other way around.
JC: Bookslut has a YA reviewer.
MS: Not unless it’s of very high literary merit or otherwise warrants consideration amongst other adult fiction.
Would you consider audiobooks for review?
MN: Doesn’t really have time to listen to audiobooks.
RH: Yes, especially in 2006. Wants to begin to feature audiobooks in podcast format and to have MP3 samples online.
MS: Would do an audiobook if it tied in with a book in an interesting fashion.
Final Comments:
RH: Mentioned the way Netflicks and Marvel Comics treat new releases as an RSS feed—this way people get new releases emailed to them weekly instead of having to look for them. Thinks this would be an excellent idea for books.
|